Vistaprint vs. Zazzle vs. Stitchi: 6 Must-Know Differences

Custom-printed merch makes for awesome gifts that not only thrill the recipients but also keep your event or brand top of mind for a long time. If you're on the hunt for cool custom gifts, you should definitely check out Vistaprint, Zazzle, and Stitchi. In this article, we’ll dive into Vistaprint vs. Zazzle vs. Stitchi to help you pick the best option for your gifting needs. We'll break down their pricing, product offerings, minimum order quantities, design tools, and shipping info. So, let’s get started and find out which one’s the perfect fit for you!

Vistaprint vs Zazzle vs Stitchi: Cost, Quality, Designing

Before ordering your custom merchandise, please check out this accurate comparison of Vistaprint, Zazzle, and Stitchi to save money and your design efforts. 

Difference 1: Product Offering

Zazzle - Best for personalized gifts for individuals and occasions like weddings, baby showers and birthday parties: Zazzle excels in creating custom gifts for weddings and special occasions, making it ideal for personal gifting options such as "gifts for parents," "gifts for her/him," "gifts for kids," and "gifts for grandparents." Customers can add special messages, quotes, and images to personalize these gifts, adding a unique touch to every item. 

Additionally, Zazzle offers a wide variety of decor and materials for weddings, baby showers, and birthday parties, including invitation cards, table numbers, tabletop signs, and thank-you gifts like candles and magnets, ensuring a memorable celebration.

Vistaprint - Best for custom merch and marketing material for corporate conferences and tradeshows: Vistaprint is a popular choice for corporate orders, specializing in tradeshow and business conference materials. It offers a comprehensive range of products such as business cards, banners, flyers, and other marketing materials that cater specifically to the needs of corporate events. Vistaprint's stationery offerings are also highly impressive, making it a go-to platform for businesses looking to create professional and cohesive branding materials.

Stitchi - Best for Bulk Custom Apparel and Bags for Employees and Students: Stitchi is renowned for its extensive selection of over 10,000 apparel and bag options, including totes, drawstrings, backpacks, and duffle bags. It is well-known for offering top-branded merchandise at significantly lower rates—at least 30% less than other platforms—when purchasing in bulk (24+ pieces). This makes Stitchi an excellent choice for businesses and educational institutions seeking high-quality custom apparel and bags for their employees and students.

Difference 2: Minimum Order Quantity

Zazzle: Zazzle does not have a minimum order quantity for personalized gifts like mugs, candles, necklaces, balls, diaries, and apparel. For wedding items such as place cards and napkins, the minimum order quantity is 50. For other products like wedding cards, the minimum order quantity ranges from 1 to 5.

VistaPrint: VistaPrint also does not have a minimum order quantity for most of its apparel. For business cards, the minimum order quantity is 100. For totes and bags, some products have no minimum order quantity, while others require minimum quantities ranging from 25 to 100. It's best to check each item individually for specific minimum order requirements.

Stitchi: Stitchi specializes in bulk orders and has a minimum order quantity of 24 pieces for all types of products.

Difference 3: Pre-Designed Merchandise

Zazzle offers a wide range of pre-designed merchandise with suitable messages like "Best Dad Ever," "Love You Mom," and more. This feature saves customers time and effort in designing. Additionally, Zazzle has a trending design section showcasing the latest designs. Neither VistaPrint nor Stitchi offers this feature.

Difference 4: Pricing

Zazzle: Zazzle is the most expensive compared to VistaPrint and Stitchi.

VistaPrint: VistaPrint falls into the mid-price range for apparel, totes, and bags. Its business cards are particularly cost-efficient.

Stitchi: Stitchi offers the lowest price range for all apparel, headwear, and bags, providing at least 30% lower rates due to its focus on bulk orders.

Difference 5: Designing Tools

Zazzle: Zazzle offers the most advanced self-designing tools among the three platforms. It provides a vast library of shapes, emojis, profession-related designs, borders, and graphics to enhance your merchandise. If you aim to create unique designs beyond simple logos or quotes, Zazzle’s design lab is an excellent choice.

VistaPrint: VistaPrint features a user-friendly drag-and-drop designing tool, which, while more generic compared to specialized apparel-focused options, is highly versatile for non-apparel products. It excels particularly in creating business cards, offering a wide array of design options and customization features.

Stitchi: Stitchi follows a different design approach. Customers submit their design ideas, logos, and images, and a dedicated designer at Stitchi will work on them to provide professional, high-resolution prints. This personalized design service is offered for 100% free, ensuring top-quality results for your custom apparel and bags.

Difference 6: Shipping

Zazzle: For standard shipping within the US, Zazzle charges between $3.99 and $6.99 per single item, with a delivery timeframe of 3–7 business days.

Premium shipping options are available at a cost ranging from $9.99 to $19.99, with a faster delivery time of 2–3 business days.

For the quickest delivery, express shipping costs between $19.99 and $29.99 and ensures your order arrives within 1–2 business days.

Zazzle also offers membership programs: Zazzle Plus and Zazzle Plus Premium.

• Zazzle Plus: For $19.95 per year, you get unlimited standard shipping on all orders for qualifying products. A free 30-day trial is available, allowing you to start saving on shipping immediately.

• Zazzle Plus Premium: Priced at $49.95 per year, this membership includes unlimited standard and premium shipping on all orders for qualifying products, providing even more flexibility and savings.

Vistaprint: It has Standard shipping in 8 business days. It is free on an order above $100. It also offers priority and express shipping options at an additional cost. Here are VistaPrint’s accurate shipping costs and speed to get a better idea. 

Stitchi: It delivers in 10 days and also has express shipping options. The exact shipping cost of the regular orders will be calculated at the checkout. They also send merchandise to multiple addresses for $5.99 per US address, which is way cheaper than all other platforms. 

Conclusion

Choosing between Zazzle, Vistaprint, and Stitchi depends on your particular needs:

• Zazzle: Ideal for individual gifts for friends or family members and decor materials for weddings, baby showers, birthday parties, and other special occasions. It has the best designing tools and pre-designed merchandise. However, it is the most expensive option of all. 

• Vistaprint: Best suited for ordering custom merchandise for corporate events, tradeshows, and conferences. It doesn’t have a minimum order quantity. Its drag-and-drop customization tool is user-friendly but not as advanced as Zazzle’s. 

• Stitchi: Perfect for bulk orders of custom apparel for employees, students, and fundraisers, offering high-quality merchandise at rates that are 30% lower than other platforms. It lets you work with a professional designer for free. It uses top-notch screen printing and embroidery for customization.